At a glance: a tool earns its place when it leaves you more capable than it found you
Wendell Berry wrote his nine standards for adopting new technology in 1987, in an essay explaining why he would not buy a computer.
Read through the lens of an independent practice, the nine rules are a test of dependency. Each one asks whether a tool leaves you more able to do the work yourself, or less.
The failures of the current generation of technology have names: a tractor that locks out its owner, an app engineered to addict, software that cannot be repaired.
Berry's list hands the experienced professional a way to judge each new tool against whether it serves the practice or just rents it.
A tool earns its place in your practice when it leaves you more capable than it found you.
The machine you cannot open
A tractor sits in a field and will not start. The engine is fine. The problem is a software error code, and the only person who can clear it is a technician the manufacturer has to send out. The farmer owns the machine. He cannot open it, and he cannot fix it himself.
Right-to-repair laws were passed because of arrangements exactly like this one. Ted Gioia tells the story as the clearest proof that new technology has stopped serving the people who buy it: manufacturers refused to sell spare parts and locked the machine until a company-trained technician arrived. The same arrangement now sits on the desk of an independent professional in different form. You pay for the tool, licence it, subscribe to it, or rent it. You cannot see inside it, and when it stops working, you cannot fix it.
The advice about tools runs one way: adopt AI or fall behind, automate more, move faster. The assumption is that a tool is good if it makes you faster, and the only question is how quickly you can adopt it.
Nine rules, written on a farm in 1987
In 1987 the Kentucky farmer and novelist Wendell Berry wrote an essay called "Why I Am Not Going to Buy a Computer." Friends kept telling him a computer would make writing easier. He answered with nine standards for adopting any new technology, and he wrote them to be simple and clear to understand:
Rule | How it fits you |
|---|---|
1 | The new tool should be cheaper than the one it replaces. |
2 | It should be at least as small in scale as the one it replaces. |
3 | It should do work that is clearly and demonstrably better than the one it replaces. |
4 | It should use less energy than the one it replaces. |
5 | If possible, it should use some form of solar energy, such as that of the body. |
6 | It should be repairable by a person of ordinary intelligence, provided that he or she has the necessary tools. |
7 | It should be purchasable and repairable as near to home as possible. |
8 | A known part should come from a small, privately owned shop or store that will take it back for maintenance or repairs. |
9 | It should not replace or disrupt anything good that already exists, and this includes family and community relationships. |

Read the nine standards and they split into two sets. Five of them (cheaper, smaller, less energy, solar or body energy, near to home) are a locality-and-scale ethic, written for a man deciding what to let onto a farm. They map awkwardly onto software, where "near to home" has no meaning and most subscriptions fail the energy test without you being able to see it.
The other four transfer directly, and those are the ones that matter for a practice: demonstrably better, repairable by ordinary intelligence, sold by a shop that takes it back, and never replacing something good that already exists.
Berry was not against tools. He wrote in longhand and his wife typed his drafts on a 1956 Royal typewriter that, as he put it, was still as good as it had ever been. The nine rules are a test for saying yes.
Rule six: can you open it?
Rule six is the one that has aged the hardest. A tool should be repairable by a person of ordinary intelligence, provided they have the necessary tools. The tractor, the ventilator, the phone you cannot open: these all fail the same way.
Gioia names the worst example, from the COVID pandemic, when manufacturers put software locks on hospital ventilators so that hospital technicians could not repair a machine people were dying for. A tool you cannot open is a tool you cannot audit.
For a professional whose value is in reading a situation and knowing what to do, that is the whole question. When a tool does part of your thinking, you want to be able to see what it did. A tool that will not let you look inside is asking you to trust it the way the farmer was asked to trust the tractor.
Rule nine: does it sit alongside what you are good at?
Rule nine is the one that matters most, and the one current technology fails most completely. A new tool should not replace or disrupt anything good that already exists, and this includes family and community relationships. Berry meant the farm, the marriage, the life around the writing. The professional version is the same test pointed at your practice: does this tool sit alongside your read on a client's situation, or does it take that read over?
Most tools do both at once. They save you time and they do some of the thinking. The useful question is whether you can check the tool's work against your own read of the situation. A tool that leaves the call with you earns its place. A tool that makes the call for you, where you cannot see how it got there, is replacing the thing you are paid for.
Gioia's list of deliberate harm is the evidence that rule nine is not abstract. Leaked documents from TikTok showed the company knew habit formation set in within roughly thirty-five minutes of watching, and built the app around it. Facebook knew Instagram worsened body image for a significant share of teenage girls. An investigation reported Spotify manipulated passive listening to reduce the royalties it paid musicians. Each of these is a technology that replaced something good, on purpose, and it is exactly what Berry's ninth rule was written to catch.
Rule eight: who benefits when you adopt it?
Rule eight asks that the tool come from a small, privately owned shop that will take it back for maintenance and repair. The modern equivalent is the question of who benefits when you adopt it. A subscription that raises its price at renewal, a platform that owns your data, an app engineered to keep you on it: in each case the shop is not taking anything back. It is keeping you.
What the nine rules catch that speed misses
Speed is real. AI makes a range of work faster. The nine rules keep asking what happens to you after you use a tool for a year. A tool that makes you faster while taking over the part of the work you are paid for is a slow trade, and the speed hides the cost.
Gioia dates the point where the industry stopped meeting these standards to the death of Steve Jobs. Technology stopped getting cheaper, stopped getting smaller, and with AI started drawing enough power to drain a grid, all while surveys show the public dislikes the tools it is being sold. The standards did not change in 1987. What changed is that the industry stopped trying to meet them.
Two tools, two verdicts
I keep my notes in plain markdown files on my own machine, in a folder I control. They hold the information for everything I do, and if the tool I open them in disappeared tomorrow, I would still have the files, and every one of them opens in a plain text editor. That is the repairability rule in practice, and it is the reason I chose this arrangement.
The other verdict is smaller. I no longer post on X. It keeps a seat in my week as a place to look and to research, and that's the part I kept. Posting just cost time and returned almost nothing, so I let that go. Run that decision through the nine rules and the posting role fails three at once: it was not clearly better than the alternatives, it came from no shop that takes anything back, and most of the benefit ran to the platform rather than to me.
The two verdicts hold the same lesson. A tool keeps the part of your practice it serves, and loses the part it does not. The markdown files serve the whole thing, so they keep it. X serves one thing now, so it keeps one seat.
Running your own stack through it
You do not need to adopt the whole list and become a smallholding farmer. Run the stack you already pay for through the four rules that transfer, and see what fails.
Start with the one question that binds all nine: does this tool leave me more capable than it found me? If a tool you adopted in the last year cannot honestly justify itself, run it through the four questions. If it fails more than it passes, let it go. The point is to own the technology you keep, and to keep only the technology that serves you.
Frequently asked questions
Do I have to apply all nine rules to every tool?
Four of the nine transfer to software; the other five are a farm-scale ethic that maps awkwardly. Run the four first: can you open it, does it sit alongside your read on a client's situation, who benefits if you adopt it, and is it demonstrably better. If a tool fails those, you have your answer without working through the rest.
Which of the nine rules matters most for an independent professional?
The ninth. A tool that replaces something good that already exists is the one that costs you the thing you are paid for. The repairability rule comes second, because a tool you cannot open is a tool you cannot audit.
How do I judge a subscription I already pay for?
Ask what it would take to leave. If leaving means losing your data, your archive, or the ability to read your own files, the tool has stopped being a tool and become a dependency, and that is a signal worth taking seriously.
References
Wendell Berry, "Why I Am Not Going to Buy a Computer", 1987. The source of the nine standards for technological innovation. Reprinted in What Are People For? (1990). https://classes.matthewjbrown.net/teaching-files/philtech/berry-computer.pdf
Ted Gioia, "9 Rules for New Technology", The Honest Broker, 9 April 2025. The framing of the nine rules as a still-current test, the dating of the industry's break with them to Steve Jobs' death, and the named failures: John Deere tractors and right-to-repair, software-locked hospital ventilators, TikTok's deliberate habit-forming design, Facebook's knowledge of Instagram's effect on body image, and the reporting on Spotify's manipulation of passive listeners. https://www.honest-broker.com/p/9-rules-for-new-technology
Next steps
If a tool you adopted in the last year cannot honestly justify itself, run it through the four questions and make the call. Write down whether it leaves you more capable or more dependent, and let it go if it fails. Keep the tools that pass, and you stop renting your practice to the ones that do not.
For more on this theme, see working with AI without losing your capabilities, AI for independent professionals, and how experienced professionals avoid the AI commoditisation trap. This article belongs in the Relational Cognition insight hub.
Wisepreneurs explores how experienced independent professionals position accumulated expertise and build sustainable practice.
Every Tuesday I send The Wisepreneur, a short letter for experienced professionals building independent practice: one usable idea a week. Sign up at wisepreneurs.com.au/newsletter
When you want a second pair of eyes on your own practice, the Positioning and Practice Audit is how I work with people: wisepreneurs.com.au/marketing-partnership